Regulation and Policy

The FCA Is Asking Whether Tokenized Gold Should Sit Outside Fund Rules. Its Price for Saying Yes Is Twelve Safeguards.

The FCA is considering whether tokenized gold should sit outside traditional fund rules, but only if issuers meet twelve safeguards covering investor protection and market integrity.

The FCA Is Asking Whether Tokenized Gold Should Sit Outside Fund Rules. Its Price for Saying Yes Is Twelve Safeguards.

On 14 September, the UK Financial Conduct Authority published a Call for Input on tokenized gold in wholesale markets, alongside a joint feedback statement with the Bank of England on tokenization more broadly. Responses close on 23 October. Most of the coverage reduced it to one line: London is considering exempting gold tokens from fund regulation.

Chapter five attaches a condition. Any wider carve-out from the collective investment scheme and alternative investment fund regimes, the FCA writes, would need to be limited to products “more appropriately regulated under a different regime providing more effective protections.” It then lists what that regime would have to cover. There are twelve items. They include the legal nature of the holder’s interest, custody and segregation of the metal, issuance and redemption, and the reconciliation of physical and onchain records, independent audit, governance over outsourced and third-party arrangements, the benchmark and valuation methodology, dealing arrangements where the issuer or an affiliate is the sole liquidity provider, and orderly wind-down on insolvency.

That is the fund, itemized. London is offering to remove the label and keep the functions.

Why industry wants out, and it is not the rulebook

The obvious reading is that issuers want lighter regulation. The paper suggests a more specific motive. Paragraph 5.9 notes that “the prudential treatment of a token and the ability to exchange it as collateral may also vary depending on whether it is classified as gold or a fund unit.”

That sentence is the commercial center of the whole consultation. Gold is high-quality collateral. A unit in an unregulated collective investment scheme is not treated the same way, and a scheme dedicated to gold cannot be a UCITS at all. An issuer whose token is classified as a fund unit has built something that cannot do the job the FCA most wants tokenized gold to do: move as wholesale collateral in repo, securities lending, and derivatives. Industry feedback asked for these products to be “expressly” excluded. The request is about eligibility on a margin call, not paperwork.

The underlying problem is real. Allocated gold gives certainty of ownership but is slow and costly to mobilize; unallocated gold moves easily but is a claim on the account provider, with the counterparty exposure that implies. And the metal and cash legs of an over-the-counter trade settle through separate systems. A token that carries allocated title at unallocated speed, settled against a dollar token in one step, would solve all three. That is the prize.

Where the FCA drew the line, and why it is the right place

The perimeter question turns on pooling. A token that directly represents ownership of a specific allocated bar, with no pooling and no collective management, is “more likely to fall outside” the definitions. Fractional interests in a single bar that is managed or disposed of collectively point the other way, and for those the FCA says the fund framework “may be the most appropriate.”

This is where the missing roles start to matter. On a whole allocated Good Delivery bar, priced against a benchmark nobody in the issuance controls, valuation is arithmetic and the claim is to a specific object in a named vault. A fund administrator adds little. On a fractional interest in a pooled or shared bar, what the token is worth in a failure depends entirely on custody records, reconciliation and the insolvency position, and those are exactly the things a fund structure assigns to someone accountable.

Collateral sharpens the point. Collateral is called when a counterparty has failed. The FCA’s own list of open legal questions includes whether a secured party receiving tokenized gold can “exercise control and realize the asset,” and how the token is treated in insolvency. For a collateral product, the twelve conditions are not a burden on the good case. They describe the bad case in advance.

The genuinely contested ground is paragraph 5.13. Industry groups have argued that tokens can represent co-ownership shares in an allocated bar and still sit outside the perimeter. The FCA says it is “open to hearing” why such arrangements would not meet every element of the definition. The argument has not yet been made.

Two answers to the same question

The Gulf got here first, by a different road.

On 8 September DMCC launched fractional interests in a single 1,971kg silver bar as an Asset-Referenced Virtual Asset under the DMCC-VARA framework. In July, the FSRA in ADGM recognized Tether Gold as an Accepted Spot Commodity. Neither went through the DFSA or FSRA fund rulebooks. Both regulators fitted the product into an existing non-fund category, which is the reason the Gulf got to market first.

London is heading toward the same label. The paper even notes that a token exempted from fund rules may still fall under the UK’s separate regime for digital assets, which is roughly where the DMCC structure started. The difference is what travels with the label. VARA’s route is cheaper because it doesn’t require fund rules. The FCA is proposing that they be required anyway, by name, as conditions of the exemption. Item eight, dealing arrangements where the issuer or an affiliate is the only source of liquidity, describes a structure the Gulf has already approved.

Neither approach is wrong. They produce different instruments. And they will meet. Gold is the collateral asset most likely to cross borders between a Dubai market that handles a large share of the world’s physical trade and London, the world’s largest spot trading market. A counterparty in one will be asked to accept a token classified under the other, and will have to work out which protections it is actually holding.

What the Shariah analysis sees in the same paper

The FCA’s lines fall, largely by accident, where a Shariah analysis would draw them too.

The paper confines itself to products that confer ownership of physical gold, which excludes unallocated claims on an account provider. The prevailing standard-setter position on gold trading also requires a specific, identified quantity held with actual or constructive possession, because a claim on a bullion bank’s pool reads as a debt, and gold debt cannot be sold for cash. The FCA’s delivery-versus-payment example, gold tokens swapped simultaneously against dollar tokens, is also the most direct way yet to meet the requirement that gold against currency change hands in the same sitting. On both points, the regulatory design helps.

The collateral use case is where it turns. Collateral mobility is valuable in conventional markets largely because a secured party can reuse what it receives. Most classical positions on rahn, the Islamic pledge, restrict what the pledgee may do with the pledged asset without the owner’s consent. An Islamic bank posting tokenized gold into a market built around reuse is operating on assumptions its Shariah board has not been asked about. Nothing in the FCA’s twelve conditions requires it to ask. Somebody in the structure does.

What to watch before 23 October

For a Gulf manager or issuer planning a product that references gold, the consultation is a useful checklist in any jurisdiction. The twelve items reasonably describe who must be named in any structure a serious counterparty will accept as collateral, and the roles that a lighter classification lets an issuer leave empty are the ones the counterparty will ask about first. Zamanat works with issuers on exactly that assembly, identifying which parties a chosen classification requires and which the eventual buyer will expect anyway.

Here is the call. The UK will not produce a clean exclusion from fund rules for fractional gold tokens. When the authorities respond, the outcome will be the paper’s third option, a recognized “eligible gold token” classification set by the Treasury and the FCA, with objective conditions drawn from the twelve items, covering direct ownership of allocated bars and admitting co-ownership structures only if they meet those conditions in full. The basis is paragraph 5.15, which already rules out any exemption that is not matched by an equivalent regime, and paragraph 4.5, which warns against “conferring credibility on poorly designed products.” If the Treasury instead legislates an unconditioned carve-out for fractional co-ownership tokens within the next twelve months, this reading is wrong, and London will have chosen the Gulf’s route rather than its own.

More from Tokenization News